TOSP Nick: jatterb
Member Since: 4/3/06
Country: USA
Blog Tagline: Sanity is overrated. I should know. I tried being sane once.




star How I became a Taylor Hicks fan













 
Alan's Blog
Saturday, January 27, 2007
To Leave a Comment or Not Leave A Comment?

Last Sunday, a Travel Golf writer named Chris Baldwin posted an entry on his blog titled "Replacing Justin Timberlake with no-talent Taylor Hicks shows how far Bob Hope Chrysler Classic's faded." In the blog, Chris gave his opinion that the Bob Hope Chrysler Classic golf tournament had sunk to a new low by replacing Justin Timberlake (who was a part of the tournament in 2006) with Taylor Hicks.

"Yes, that Taylor Hicks. The prematurely gray-haired moron from American Idol, the worst show in the history of television. How low can the Bob Hope people go?"
Needless to say, Chris' blog entry riled up the Soul Patrol in a big way. At the time of this writing, 155 comments have been left behind, the overwhelming majority of which slammed Chris with both feet. The previous 10 entries in Chris' blog averaged 7.7 comments.

So Chris Baldwin did the only thing he could do in this situation. He posted a second blog entry about Taylor two days later, this one titled "Taylor Hicks' Soul Patrol of imbeciles no match for us Wie Warriors." This time, Chris took direct aim at the Soul Patrol.

"When you write a golf blog as pure as the first fresh snow like I do, you learn a few things along the way. This week for instance, I discovered that an American Idol hack named Taylor Hicks has a small band of overweight desperate housewives for fans who call themselves with much third-grade pride the Soul Patrol. These are the kind of people whose husbands always play 36 holes and never want to go home."
Chris struck gold again, this time with a whopping 201 comments. In the five blog entires following, he has averaged 3.3 comments.

The second blog entry created quite a stir on the TOSP forum. No, not because he called us "overweight desperate housewives" (though, for the record, I do want to say that I'm not desperate, I'm not a housewife, and after I get back from the gym I'll tell you I'm not overweight). The stir was created because many people felt that the only reason Chris wrote the second blog entry was because of the huge comment response he had gotten the first time.

Most bloggers thrive on the comments that are left behind by their visitors. It doesn't matter whether these comments are positive or negative. All that matters is that comments are left behind. When a blog subject results in a higher-than-normal number of comments, chances are another blog entry on the same subject won't be too far behind.

And that's exactly what happened with Chris and his blog. The first entry about Taylor resulted in a 2000% increase in the number of comments being left, most of which were negative towards Chris. So he made a second blog entry, this time attacking the Soul Patrol directly.

So would Chris have made the second blog entry if the Soul Patrol had not left all of those comments behind? More than likely he would not have. He would have gone on to the next topic and not given it a second thought. And that is why there are a group of Soul Patrollers who strenously, and repeatedly, encourage their fellow Taylor Hicks fans to not leave behind a comment on a blog that attacks Taylor. These Soul Patrollers say that when you do, you only encourage the writer to post another negative blog entry about Taylor and/or his fans.

What do you think? Should the Soul Patrol not leave behind a comment on a blog entry that attacks Taylor? Could you restrain yourself from typing the first thing that comes behind when you read a blog entry like the one that Chris Baldwin posted?

Leave me a comment and let me know what you think. Who knows..... if enough comments are left, I might just talk about this again.


Tags: , , ,






7 Comments:

Great job Alan. I really enjoyed reading this and got a little chuckle out of the number of people that "drop kicked" the writer. No one likes to hear bad things about Taylor. He is such a great guy. He is just a sweetheart and his heart is in the right place. I maybe be a housewife and maybe a little overweight, but I'm definitely NOT desperate. Besides, I'm married.:D

Great entry! You are so right about our responding to these nuts, aka Taylor haters. I responded to Chris myself, but later wished I hadn't, for the very reason you state we shouldn't. Maybe if the Soul Patrol behaved more like Taylor, we'd get better press too! After all, Taylor just lets it roll off his back, and so should we!

I agree, we should keep our mouths shut. Instead, we should focus our energy on leaving positive messages for people who have positive things to say. Let's leave a GOOD impression, Soul Patrol!

I love reading your posts, Alan. I commented on Chris' blog the first time and how I regretted that I did.It's just that these women that he called overweight and desperate are just overprotective of Taylor, we are his mother hens. I am not overweight, and I am not desperate either, but Taylor brings me joy each time I see him and hear him sing. But so what if we are overweight and desperate???

I'm maybe overweight but I'm not desperate and a housewife..Besides, who cares really?! I'm just loving every Taylor moment.

Make a provocative statement and you elicit a response, either positive or negative. A lot of these sites incite their readers to draw more attention to themselves (or their site), whether it be right or wrong. As much as we don't want to fuel the fire, sometimes we just feel the need to fight for what we believe in. If we run, we are, in essence, agreeing with the comment. So, fight or flight, right? It's a double-edged sword.

I really enjoyed reading that, well most of it. I might be overwieght and a housewife but I am certainly not desperate. The best people love Taylor Hicks. My 9 year old niece thinks JT is gross but she loves Taylor and knows the songs on his nnew album by heart. Back to us, when people grow together and become as strong and unified as the Soul Patrol is, people become insecure and they have to reassure themselves by saying we are something less than desirable so they will feel better about themselves. Well, my soul patrol baby wants her mommy. Great blog, Alan

Post a Comment

Powered by Blogger




Forum |  Chat |  Media |  Photos |  Store |  News |  Bio |  Links

MySpace |  Contact |  Advertise |  Home



TheOfficialSoulPatrol.com is the home of the original Soul Patrol, dedicated to Taylor Hicks.
TheOfficialSoulPatrol.com is in no way affiliated with Taylor Hicks, FremantleMedia, FOX or American Idol.
All registered trademarks are property of their respective vendors/owners.

Copyright © 2006 - 2007